Template talk:Warn
Other warning text suggestions
Here's what I think some other warnings should look like. Those are more akin to the warnings you see on products and in product manuals and use similar graphics and phrasing. I expected those will be dismissed as rubbish red tape by some experienced repair technicians but they are not the target, the target is someone inexperienced, probably a kid who stumbles across this wiki trying to fix a game console who has no clue what they're doing along with any lawyers and government regulators.
If you're happy with those I'll write the template code for them later this week.
Large banner div warnings
Those should only be necessary to put those on guide pages that directly give safety advice about a topic (example)
Medium box warnings
Those could probably be put at the top of the disassembly notes or in an infobox under the device infobox on the right hand side of the page. (example)
DANGER This device has exposed high voltage and intentionally defeats earth leakage circuit breakers. |
WARNING This device contains a high voltage CRT. |
CAUTION This device is mains powered. |
NOTE This device is subject to strict regulations in some regions, modifications may be unlawful. |
Small in-line warnings
For use in instructions about specific things (now sure how much people would use those but they could be useful)
DANGER Capacitor C5 is 2 kV 125 μF (300 J).
WARNING Those 450 V capacitors do not have bleeder resistors.
CAUTION This heatsink has very sharp edges.
NOTE The sensor window is extremely fragile.
WizardTim (talk) 10:55, 9 February 2022 (UTC)
I really like these and would like to implement them. The way I've been making the templates won't work well for this though because it's using if-then's to substitute based on strings and this really needs something like a drop down menu to choose which kind to use for probably both the warning icon/color and the size. @Lyiriyah: , do you know enough about templates to do something like that?
I do won't if we should simplify to three options like "DANGER", "CAUTION", "NOTE" since "WARNING" and "CAUTION" mean fairly similar things and the colors become less distinct. That way the severity of the warning is immediately obvious. And it would make it easier to decide which ones to use as well.
--AkBKukU (talk) 13:13, 11 February 2022 (UTC)
- I haven’t done much with Wiki templates but I can probably figure it out if needed, I’d probably implement them as three different templates probably ‘warn-banner’, ‘warn-box’ and ‘warn-inline’.
- I strongly recommend sticking to those words as they’re standardised in hazard communication worldwide across languages and not only in the electronics industry. You can give the advice of “the template word you use should match what is written on the device”
- The difference between them in summary is:
- DANGER – Situation that will result in serious injury or death.
- WARNING – Situation could result in serious injury or death.
- CAUTION – Situation could result moderate or minor injury.
- NOTE – Situations unrelated to injury or things related to property damage or legal implications.
- WizardTim (talk) 13:41, 11 February 2022 (UTC)